A/B Testing in Digital Marketing: A Detailed Guide for Small Businesses
July 21, 2023
Small businesses operate in a unique environment — one where the boundary between thriving and just getting by is often blurred.
In such a scenario, understanding and leveraging digital marketing can be a powerful tool. It offers a chance to reach out to a wider audience, engage with customers more dynamically and, ultimately, influence the growth trajectory of the business.
A key component of this digital marketing toolkit is A/B testing.
At its most basic level, A/B testing involves comparing two versions of a digital asset to determine which performs better. This could be anything from a landing page to an email campaign or even a social media ad.
Now, let’s use an analogy to understand this better. Imagine you’re running a small bakery. You have a sneaking suspicion that your popular chocolate chip cookies would sell better if they were placed on the counter rather than hidden away in a display case.
How would you test this theory? You might try placing the cookies on the counter for one week, then back in the display case for the next week. By comparing the sales each week, you’d be able to determine which location is more effective.
This, in essence, is what A/B testing in digital marketing is all about.
The nitty-gritty of A/B testing in digital marketing
In the digital world, A/B testing can be thought of as a scientific experiment. It starts with a hypothesis (e.g., “Version B of my landing page will generate more conversions than Version A”), followed by a testing phase where both versions are exposed to different segments of your audience simultaneously.
The version that results in better conversion rates, as determined by the metric you’ve set (e.g., clicks, form submissions, sales, etc.), wins the test.
The beauty of A/B testing is its ability to bring clarity to what works and what doesn’t in your digital marketing efforts. It enables you to figure out what exactly resonates with your audience, providing data-driven insights that can guide your strategy.
For small businesses, this is particularly significant. Without the luxury of large marketing budgets or extensive resources, understanding how to make the most of every effort becomes paramount.
That’s where A/B testing comes in, offering a cost-effective way to optimize and refine your strategies over time.
Putting A/B testing into action for your small business
Implementing A/B testing into your small business marketing may seem a little daunting at first. But with a step-by-step approach, it can be an accessible, straightforward process. Let’s break it down.
Step #1: Pinpointing your testing goals
The first step to successful A/B testing is to identify what you’re looking to achieve. In other words, you need to set a clear, measurable goal.
Maybe you want to drive more traffic to your website, or perhaps you’re trying to boost sales for a particular product. Or, maybe you’re looking to increase the open rates for your email newsletters.
Just like our bakery owner who was looking to sell more cookies, your testing goal should align with a broader business objective. This way, the insights you gain from your tests can directly inform and improve your marketing efforts.
Step #2: Crafting the A and B versions
Once you have a clear goal, it’s time to create your two versions -— Version A (the control) and Version B (the variation).
Remember, you’re trying to figure out what change can influence your desired outcome. This means you should only alter one element between the two versions.
For instance, if you’re testing a landing page, you could modify the headline, the call-to-action button or the color scheme. If it’s an email campaign, consider changing the subject line or the placement of key information.
The idea is to isolate one variable for testing so you can accurately gauge its impact.
Step #3: Dividing your audience
Next, you’ll need to split your audience into two roughly equal and representative groups. One group will see Version A, the other will see Version B.
It’s crucial that these groups are comparable in terms of size and composition. If one group is significantly larger or consists of different demographics, it could skew your test results.
Step #4: Running the test
With your versions ready and your audience segmented, it’s time to let the test run. This phase is all about gathering data, so it’s essential to give your test enough time.
Depending on the size of your audience and the nature of your business, this could range from a few days to a few weeks. The key is to ensure you gather enough data for your results to be statistically significant.
Step #5: Delving into the data
After your test period ends, it’s time to analyze the results. This involves comparing the performance of Version A against Version B based on the metric you’ve chosen.
Did one version lead to more website visits? Did it increase the number of product purchases? Understanding these results will guide you in implementing the more successful version and planning future tests.
The impact of A/B testing on small business marketing
When used correctly, A/B testing can greatly enhance your marketing efforts. The continuous cycle of testing, analyzing and implementing allows you to make incremental improvements to your strategies.
Consider a small bookstore that sends out weekly newsletters. A/B testing can reveal whether a “10% off” banner or a “Buy one, get one free” banner generates more website visits.
Similarly, if you run a local coffee shop, you can use A/B testing to discover if customers are more likely to click on an ad featuring a tantalizing shot of your coffee varieties or a cozy image of your shop interior.
This ability to learn more about your customers’ preferences and optimize your strategies accordingly is what makes A/B testing such a powerful tool for small businesses.
Avoiding the pitfalls of A/B testing
Despite its numerous benefits, A/B testing also comes with potential pitfalls that need to be considered.
One common error is making conclusions based on incomplete or inaccurate data. If your test doesn’t run long enough or your sample size is too small, your results may not be reliable.
Additionally, testing too many variables at once can muddle your results. For example, if you change the color scheme, headline and call-to-action button between Version A and Version B, how will you know which change drove a different outcome?
Remember, the key to successful A/B testing is isolating and testing one variable at a time.
Taking the leap: Elevate your small business marketing with A/B testing
In the ever-evolving digital marketing landscape, small businesses need every advantage they can get. One of the most potent tools at their disposal is A/B testing.
With its ability to offer data-driven insights, A/B testing empowers businesses to understand their audience better, make informed decisions and continually optimize their strategies for the best results.
Are you ready to take your small business marketing to the next level? Are you excited about the potential A/B testing holds for your business?
If so, we invite you to learn more and see our plans and pricing. Our marketing analytics software — the Intelligence app — makes it easy to see what’s working and what’s not in your small business marketing strategy.
Get Plans and Pricing Below
Get the know-how to get ahead
Get business, marketing and sales tips written by experienced industry practitioners. 100% free. Cancel anytime.